Categories
Uncategorized

Masks: compliance, tolerance, excuses

Before I started training as a teacher, one of the things I worried most about was “behaviour management”. There is an idea – exemplified in the ridiculous phrase “don’t smile until Christmas” – that new teachers will not have the required toughness or authoritarian heft to ‘control a class’ until they’ve perfected a stony-faced expression and impressed their stony-mindedness on their classes for several months in a row. I worried about this, because I am not, and have never been, tough. I have a soft face, a soft voice, and I’m a chronic people-pleaser. I tend to wear my emotions on my sleeve, and the idea of not smiling for several months in a row was ridiculous – how could I control my face for that long? My face just does what it wants. I did not think “behaviour management” would be a strength of mine.

As I moved through my training, it soon became apparent that my skill in “behaviour management” very much depended on what you meant by the term. My classrooms were often noisy, often a little chaotic, but I had good relationships with my classes. I realised over time that there was a split in my ability to ‘manage’ students. I was good at persuading students to do things I cared about them doing – ask me when you need help, work together, give things a try, don’t hurt others. I remember I once explained to a pair of year 7 boys why they should stop saying the word “triggered” as a joke, going into detail about how it trivialises PTSD, and was stunned by the sincerity of their apology and commitment not to say it again. I think they had responded to my own sincerity in asking them. Conversely, I wasn’t at all effective with rules I didn’t believe in. Chewing gum, forgetting your pencil, looking out the window or not wearing your uniform properly – I just didn’t care about these things. When I performed caring about them because it was expected of me, my students saw right through it.

This is one of many reasons I could never survive teaching in a zero tolerance/no excuses school. The idea behind these schools’ policies is that compliance itself is a virtue worth teaching: that students need to learn the skill of compliance so that they can go on to be compliant as adults. This is not grand theorising on my part: it’s very clear in the policies themselves, which emphasise following instructions straight away without question. It’s all there in the ‘No Excuses’ slogan – nothing you might say to explain or excuse your behaviour will change the punishment I, an adult, am giving you. My word is law because it is my word.

It’s important not to forget that, as teachers, we are all relying on some degree of compliance. Fundamentally, our students are all compelled to be there (via legal obligations on their parents), so we can’t pretend to be operating in an environment totally free of force and obligation. As well as simply being in the room, we need to be able to prevent our students from coming to harm: we need to know that if we say “stop” as they are running out into the road, they will listen. Beyond that, it’s mostly about convenience and the logistics of having a large group of people together in one room. We might want students to lower their voices when asked so that we can hear ourselves think in the classroom. We might want them to pick up their stuff from the floor so the room doesn’t get in a mess. I found that I was by far the most effective at persuading students to do these things if I explained why I wanted them. “Please remember to write the date, because when I mark your books it takes me ages to find the work otherwise” proved much more effective than implying that there’s any intrinsic moral value in writing the date. “Please be a little quieter so we can all hear what we’re doing, plus it’s really boring and annoying for all of us if I have to keep shushing you all the time” proved much more effective than trying to enforce silence for its own sake.

In some ways, zero tolerance/no excuses settings are explicit about this dynamic. They have no shame in stating that you should act in ways which are convenient for your teacher. The difference is that they assign this compliance-with-convenience moral virtue, and make it totally non-negotiable. While it might be more convenient for me if all my students are quiet while they’re working, it’s not what they naturally want to do, and so there’s a negotiation: how much am I going to try to persuade them to act differently, and how much is it worth it? In zero tolerance/no excuses there is no such negotiation: the teacher learns that they automatically have the right to dictate their will. They don’t have to think about why they want something, or the balance of benefits and drawbacks for everyone in the room. The student learns to comply with the person in power, and learns that compliance is good.

You might think, then, that zero tolerance/no excuses schools would be perfectly positioned to impose the mask-wearing mandate that’s recently been introduced (or has it? or will it be? I have no fucking clue any more, honestly) for secondary schools. Come September, I was fully expecting to see gloating photos of perfectly masked-up children in ZT/NE schools, along with snarky comments about how don’t we all wish we worked in schools where students were conditioned to do what they were told? Surely if there is one argument for compliance, it’s the example above about running out into the road, and a mass public health crisis seems to be about as close to that as we’re going to get. Don’t these people love uniforms?

It seems I will be spared the gloating class photos, however, because the ZT/NE crowd have come out against masks. In retrospect this was predictable: they are deeply connected to the far right, and rely on being able to broadcast their dog whistles in the education sphere. The far right have decided anti-mask sentiment is a handy talking point and recruitment tool – quite a clever one, since masks are kind of annoying and uncomfortable, the government’s policy on them has been totally inconsistent and confusing. And so the ZT/NE media stars have to be anti-masks too, which puts them in a fascinating rhetorical position: they must simultaneously claim that their schools create perfect environments of compliance, and also that it would be cataclysmic to ask their students to do something according to a government directive. If they can make their students walk silently through the corridors; if they can make them track teachers with their eyes at all times (yes, they do this: google SLANT); if they have the incredibly high levels of attendance they claim to have; can they not make them wear masks? Can they not make them behave sensibly with a mask on?

The answer is obvious: they could, but they don’t want to. This is what’s laid bare by the convoluted rhetorical gymnastics they’re doing in order to stick to the far right anti-mask hymn sheet. When it really comes down to it, they’re like me. They don’t want to enforce rules they don’t care about. Their claim to be teaching compliance as a moral virtue and useful life skill falls apart: it’s not that they want kids to be able to follow rules in general. They want kids to be able to follow their rules that they like, and they only like rules that perpetuate hierarchy and prop up their ideological project.

In resisting this, I think we need to be careful that we’re not just echoing the ZT/NE compliance obsession. I know it’s frustrating that such an apparently simple thing is being turned into an extremist talking point: believe me, I spend most of my time freaked out about this kind of thing. But responding with incredulity that anyone could possibly be so stupid as to doubt mask-wearing is playing into the far right’s hands. Anti-mask feeling is such an effective recruiting tool because it plays on people’s confusion and powerlessness in the face of the pandemic. Yelling “WEAR A MASK, STUPID” just fuels that. We can’t just expect compliance for its own sake. We have to make our case, we have to say why it matters, we have to build relationships.Our media and political discourse are in a terrible, terrifying place, and I’m not naïve enough to think that just being ourselves and hoping for the best will fix it all. But I know that I was never able to persuade people based on compliance first: I had to tell them why I cared.

Categories
Uncategorized

On the side of the angels – our heroes, between two deaths

Image

It’s been getting worse for weeks, the breathtaking hypocrisy, the #clapping and #solidarity with healthcare workers with no meaningful action to make their conditions better, indeed from people who’ve consistently voted to make their conditions worse. I’ve tried not to be too miserly: the rainbows in the windows might be sweet for children, the clapping might have been moving for some people. But this front page takes a step beyond that.

“On the side of the angels” is a song title, and it’s got a reassuring cadence to it. It’s like the funeral cliché, “he’s with the angels now”. Because although this front page claims to be “raising cash” – as if charity donations for a supposedly public health service are anything but tragic – it’s doing more than that. Suspended in the sky, the row of white women (and one brown man) smile uncannily; while the rest of us panic, they laugh; while the rest of us suffer in our selfishness, they are safe, because they are angels.

“He’s with the angels now” means that he’s dead. Angels live in the afterlife. Depending on where angels fit in your theology, perhaps they intervene on the earthly plane, but not materially. Angels don’t get coughed on or clean up sick or attach ventilators – they don’t reach into this world with their bodies. Maybe they were once people, but not now.

Angels do not need to be paid, or given masks.

The French psychoanalyst Lacan says that we die twice; once materially, when our bodies cease to function, and once symbolically, when society acknowledges our death. Strange things happen when the two kinds of death don’t line up: we end up in the zone “between two deaths”. When natural death happens before symbolic death, when bodies die before society is ready for it, we get dead bodies refusing to die, ghosts and zombies, lifeless bodies which keep pushing for acknowledgement, rattling the doors and howling. Symbolic death without natural death is less ghoulish but more real and chilling; Lacan’s example is Antigone, walled up in a cave and dead to society, already dead in all but biological fact.

They’re with the angels now: they are the angels now. These angels, these nurses, these heroes, who float above us, who we throw our spare pennies at in the hope of a blessing; in this front page, they are already symbolically dead. It is entirely in the interests of the right wing press to announce this symbolic death — so that when their natural death comes, and it will, we will be less shocked. Angels ascend, heroes die, it was always going to happen, it has already happened. There was never anything to be done.

 

Categories
Uncategorized

Culture, curriculum, richness and resonance – Mozart vs. Stormzy, or JS Bach vs. Weird Kids’ YouTube

In 2019, a charity called Youth Music called for an “urgent transformation” of the music curriculum in the UK. Youth Music had designed a bespoke music curriculum around grime and hip-hop, with the help of the music industry, and delivered it to to 974 young people in UK schools at risk of exclusion. They found that these students went on to have generally higher attendance rates, a lower risk of exclusions, and better maths and English scores. These were unequivocally good results, and shouldn’t have been controversial at all – but this is to grossly underestimate the power of the UK media, and the UK education discussion sphere, to make a culture war out of anything at all.

Because despite the excellent results from this charity’s work, despite its sensible and uncontroversial recommendations to the DfE for an engaging and vibrant music curriculum, just one soundbite from the press release made it into headlines. The charity’s director said “we’ve seen the benefits of students exchanging Mozart for Stormzy as part of a re-imagined music curriculum”. This was presumably a bit of rhetorical flourish meant to imply swapping old for new, classical for modern – but it was reproduced in the press as a diktat, a suggestion that all schools should do a Find and Replace on their syllabus, extract all the Mozart, and parachute in Stormzy as a direct replacement. The pseudo-debate had racist overtones – or perhaps just tones – as pictures of Stormzy tearing it up at Glastonbury were put next to serene oil paintings of Mozart, and the charity’s suggestion was reformulated into a demand:

Screenshot 2020-02-01 at 15.31.36.png
From The Sun. No, I’m not providing a link.

 

Image result for stormzy orchestra"
A typical image from media coverage of this story, this one from Sky News. Note Stormzy positioned as if he’s yelling directly at Mozart, and Mozart looking like he’s about to say that he doesn’t like Stormzy’s tone.

This, of course, led to frenzies from the right wing of edutwitter, pitting Stormzy and Mozart against each other like pro-wrestlers competing for the one coveted Music Curriculum Spot. As if any music teacher would make their curriculum a binary choice between these two, as if the two artists are totally unconnected by an unbridgeable gulf. While the progressive side of edutwitter mounted a spirited defence of the cultural value of Stormzy, there was (with some notable exceptions) not much critical discussion of how this needless culture war had been constructed in the first place, what cultural ‘value’ actually means, and whether these are terms we want to be fighting on. The smartest responses were from Youth Music themselves and from Stormzy, both of whom rejected the terms of the “debate”:

https://twitter.com/stormzy/status/1131482542337667072?s=20

 

In my corner of teaching practice, I don’t have to deal directly with much of this nonsense. This is because UK headline writers, and Tory edutwitter, and the government itself, are largely uninterested in what is taught in specialist schools.¹ Nobody is getting very upset about whether my kids, who have severe learning disabilities, get Stormzy or Mozart. Which is just as well, because it would not mean a great deal. My students don’t have a conception of the difference between so-called prestige and popular culture. “Relevance”, to them, is perceived and judged from moment to moment – do I want this? Do I like this? Do my senses and my interests make me want more of this, or less? They do not know or care that Mozart is dead or that Stormzy just headlined Glastonbury.

I have music every day in my classroom – it helps the students to settle into the room after break times. Disney songs are popular choices, as well as some of the slightly trippier corners of kids’ YouTube – they love music from the Learning Station, including this, which is probably our class’s current favourite:

It’s brightly coloured, it’s bouncy, it has silly actions, it has a large man inexplicably dressed as a small boy with an eerily fixed smile. It’s relevant to them because it meets their needs in that moment – they need to move, they need actions to copy, they need something familiar. And it’s got jokes in, it’s joyful. (In case you’re wondering how I ever get it out of my head… I don’t).

On Thursday, we had a professional cellist come to visit us. She happens to be a parent of a child in the class, and we have just had an Arts Week where we were encouraged to take time off-timetable for arts-related things. I didn’t give her any direction – she just brought her cello and played some Bach for us. The children were utterly transfixed – we don’t have anything like a school orchestra, so most of them hadn’t seen a cello before, let alone been so close to one. It can take a lot to capture their attention, but sitting in a circle looking at the cello, they were silent. They took turns to come to the centre of the circle and have a go at playing it, feeling the resonances through their whole bodies, exploring what happened when they moved the bow.

The students seemed delighted by the experience, as did all the adults watching. Part of the joy for us, I think, was seeing our students – who, we know, have to live in a world which generally does not want to include them – have an experience like this. Seeing our students play the cello felt radical and exciting precisely because our students do not normally get to play the cello. Part of me felt troubled to be feeling this way. Isn’t this just holding up the “prestige” vs. “relevance” debate again? Is there anything intrinsically more special about a cello than a homemade shaker or a plastic boomwhacker?

The answer, I think, is in following my students’ example and escaping sideways from these hierarchies. They loved the cello because of its physical existence in the world as an object, as a thing which made sound and vibration in a way they hadn’t seen or felt before. The deep resonance of the wood, the fragility and texture of the bow, its size and shininess. They wanted to be around it, wanted more of it. This is the same with the kids in the Youth Music study and their amazing-sounding grime curriculum – it made them want to be there. It boosted their attendance and reduced their risk of being excluded because in very simple terms, it made them want to show up.

The obvious answer to “Stormzy vs. Mozart” is Stormzy and Mozart, and The Learning Station and Bach and and and and, all of it, as much as possible. Stormzy knows this, I think Mozart probably knew it. We want our students to be able to be curious, to ask, what makes me want more? What do my senses need and want in this moment? What moves me? I believe these questions, and providing a rich variety of possible answers to them, are at the heart of what we are doing when we educate students in the arts from the early years to higher education. Youth Music knew it and I was reminded of it this week. As ever, when you pay attention outside the mainstream, you find the answers that would help everyone have a richer and more resonant life.

 


  1. It’s not that there aren’t vital discussions to be had about the specialist school curriculum, about what and who our curriculum is for – if anything, these discussions are more urgent than those about neurotypical and abled children. When our students leave the education system at 19, or 25 if they manage to hang onto their legal entitlement, they will enter an ever-more-hostile world where their opportunities for supported employment and living have been cut to almost nothing by austerity and pre-existing indifference. How can we teach them to survive in this world? How much do we concede to this status quo, and how much do we insulate them from it within our walls?
Categories
Uncategorized

Making one whole body – the hard work of losing diet culture

In August this year, I wrote a piece about my body. I wrote about how I have seen it and felt about it over the years, as it has grown, as I have gone from below-the-national-average-size to above it, and how it’s been impacted by the life-changing brain injury I acquired nearly a year ago now. I’d encourage you to go back and read it if you didn’t at the time, because this piece is a companion and a follow-up to it. But to summarise quickly: ever since I was a teenager, I have thought my body was too big, and tried to shrink it, and it has continued to grow anyway. This year, after severe injury, I’ve finally stopped trying to shrink it, and tentatively begun to accept and even celebrate it.

After I wrote that piece back in August, my friend josie and I had a conversation about it. It is very often the case that josie’s reading of my work expands and extends my thinking, and this was no exception. This was one of the first times I’d written openly about seeing my body negatively, been open about internalised fat-hatred and trying to change myself. Josie wanted to apologise for not having known before that this was how I felt: she said at times she’d even felt envious of me for having the “right attitude” – in air quotes we both understood – to my body, while she had struggled with disordered patterns. I said that no apology was needed, because appearing to have the “right attitude” – performing body positivity – had been a part of the cycle I’d been stuck in, somewhere between viscerally despising my body and trying to pretend I didn’t have one. Sometimes I had really tried very hard to affect liking my body for a while, before swinging back to hating it. Because really, they were two sides of the same coin – make myself better by getting slimmer and more attractive, or make myself better by becoming a beautiful beacon of body positive self-love.

Our conversation revealed that while I’d been envying josie’s proximity to the “right” body shape, she’d been envying my performance of the “right” attitude. We both understood the irony and what it meant. I joked that, between us, we almost added up to one (1) socially acceptable person. But of course, the imagined hybrid-person couldn’t possibly exist, because the “right” attitude and the “right” body are not only both impossible, they’re even more impossible to hold at the same time. The only way to get the “right” body is to push, punish, restrict, withhold. And the only way to get the “right” attitude is to be carefree and unaffected. Attaining one, even if it were possible, would preclude attaining the other.

Image result for dove real beauty
An image from Dove’s “Real Beauty” campaign, otherwise known as being incredibly conventionally attractive and performing “acceptance” of one apparent “flaw”, such as “freckles” or “having short hair”

I have had this follow-up piece in mind ever since my conversation with josie, but I am moved to write it now because of the date. It’s a new year soon, and this is the first New Year I can remember where I haven’t resolved to lose weight in some form. Some years the resolution would be explicit – a trip to the bathroom scales, a goal, a number, an app – but some years, and increasingly more recently, it would be a guilty secret, buried in my heart. Guilty because I’ve known I’m not supposed to want it. I’m supposed to love my body, to be indifferent to constant cultural messaging telling me it’s horrendous. I’m supposed to be too smart for diet culture. So I would tell myself it wasn’t about weight. “It’s just about health”, “it’s just about exercise”, “it’s just about taking 10,000 steps in a day, because that’s for some reason extremely important“. Every time I’d tell myself something like this, there’d be a hopeful little voice that said “… and you might lose some weight, too!”. I was trying to be that mythical, wholly socially acceptable person – to rise above diet culture, but magically get thin anyway, just by accident. Right body and right attitude.

Except of course when I inevitably didn’t lose weight with each of these efforts, when I got fit enough to run a 10K, but still didn’t drop any dress sizes, the little voice that was hoping I might lose weight would get louder, drop its mask and become hateful. And this time I had double the reason to hate myself, because I’d failed twice over – at changing my body and at loving it. “You stupid bitch, you can’t even love yourself properly” might seem like a ridiculous thought if you’ve never struggled with a self-sabotaging brain – but if you have, hopefully you’ll understand.

Screenshot 2019-12-29 at 21.30.09.png
Rachel Bloom as Rebecca Bunch singing “You Stupid Bitch” in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, the most immense Mood if you have a brain like ours

So what has changed this year? Well, I explain some of that in my previous post – but essentially, what happened was brain injury. For most of this year, there has been absolutely no question of dieting or exercise – I had to just get through each day, build my strength for getting out of the house, going back to work. All of my effort, physically and cognitively, has gone into reconstructing the levels of activity I had before. So trying to add more activity, or trying to restrict calories when I’m always approaching my last scrap of energy, just hasn’t been possible. And I put on weight. And there was no question of “doing anything about it” by trying to lose it. I had to accept I was at maximum capacity already. So when the feelings of body-hatred came – and they did, intensely – I no longer had the choice between trying to change my body and trying to change my attitude to escape them. The “body” option had been taken off the table – attitude was the only thing left.

Realising this, I set about trying to change my mindset like all the other times I had tried. But my hopes were not high – it had never worked before, after all. But this time was different. Maybe because the “try to lose weight” option had been definitively removed, but also because this time I’ve been able to learn from others whose perspectives helped me escape the narrative of self-love as just another self-improvement initiative. In the Q&A at a Sofie Hagen gig, the first event I’d been to outside the house since my brain injury, I asked Sofie about how they deal with feelings of perfectionism around body positivity – how do you stop yourself trying to be the best and most body positive person ever? Their answer was to gently correct me on the use of ‘positivity’. You don’t have to be positive, they said – you just have to be neutral. It’s not realistic to expect yourself to be radiant with love about your own ankles every day – you’re just a human being who has ankles. Being able to think that thought, without revulsion – that’s the goal. And then maybe replace ankles with legs. And then – harder – thighs, and even stomach. These are body parts. You’re a human who has them.

Sofie’s book also really helped me. A confession that shows how much I needed it: at first, I was nervous to read it in public with the cover showing. What if people saw me reading a book called Happy Fat, and thought that I was… well, happy with being fat? The shame I felt at that idea was deeply illustrative in itself, and reading the book on the bus became a proxy for dealing with all my other feelings – as I progressed through it, I began to hold it up straighter in front of me, Sofie’s gorgeous cover more and more visible to onlookers. At the back of the book, there’s a list of instagram accounts to follow which feature beautiful photography by and of fat people – I followed them all, so my feed is now a riot of colour and joy and tummies and thighs and bums. And slowly, slowly, I began to move towards the neutrality that Sofie described. Not constant, not foolproof – it probably never will be – but slowly but surely more secure.

Just recently, I’ve read No Big Deal by Bethany Rutter, a young adult fiction novel about a fat seventeen year old named Emily. In some ways it’s a typical YA novel of the type I’d have loved as a teen – coming-of-age, boy drama, witty asides – but in other ways it’s extraordinary. Emily is fat, but. She isn’t on a diet, she isn’t mired in self-hatred, she isn’t apologetic. She fundamentally likes her body. At the beginning of the novel there’s a scene where she gets dressed for a party in front of the mirror. Despite knowing that Bethany Rutter had written this book, when I visualised Emily walking up to the mirror and looking at herself I still felt a shudder of dread: programmed by twenty eight years of consuming mainstream culture, I expected her to look in the mirror and sigh, cry, grab rolls of her stomach, wistfully visualise a perfect thin version of herself, and then throw on a black sack. But she doesn’t.

Standing in my perfectly high-waisted Marks and Spencer black knickers and my T-shirt bra, I see cute freckles over my face, light brown hair dangling to my chest that’s gorgeous and thick (so I can tolerate the frizziness), pale blue eyes that don’t even need accentuating with brown eyeshadow (…), slightly overlapping front teeth . . . and fat.

There’s a lot of fat.

Soft, pale thighs, squidgy tummy, deliciously squishy upper arms, round bum… not so much in the way of boobs… OK – enough posing. This outfit isn’t going to choose itself.

No Big Deal, pp. 12-13

Emily knows she’s fat. She knows what her body looks like and it’s not painful to her. There are parts she loves, parts she’s ambivalent about. The novel doesn’t erase the difficulties of moving through the world as a fat person – it begins with Emily getting stuck in a too-small dress in Topshop – but those difficulties all come from the outside world, shop sizing and diet ads and useless boys. The mirror scene – and the whole novel – makes it clear over and over that there’s nothing wrong with Emily’s body, only people’s reactions to it. She doesn’t envy her thin friends’ bodies – she envies their freedom to move through the world without being forced to think about their weight.

As Sofie and Bethany both articulate beautifully in their work, there’s a reason that forcing “body positivity” on myself never worked. It’s because, like the prospect of weight loss, “body positivity” as a mainstream, corporate-feminist concept is just as unattainable. As Bethany says in the afterword to No Big Deal, 

real, meaningful self-acceptance has to be based on truth rather than illusion, and you can’t truly accept a body you don’t accept you have.

This is as true for bodies as it is for minds. The illusion of a self-loving, relentlessly positive mindset is alluring and beautiful – but it’s an illusion just like a thin body. And just like a thin body, it can’t be magicked into being – and the harder you try, the more you try to force yourself to fit into a certain shape, the more it will hurt. Diet culture, misogyny, corporate vested interests in our self-loathing – all of these are real material forces, having a real impact and doing real harm in the world. Escaping their clutches takes real, difficult work, that never really ends.

I’m committed to trying, though, in the hope that if I have a daughter, it won’t take a brain injury to force her to accept the body she has. Hopefully, with more work like Bethany’s and Sofie’s, she might be able to take that as a given, and the concepts of having the “right body” and the “right attitude” will each be as meaningless as the other.

Categories
Uncategorized

Body images

content notes: dieting, size (including numbers), calorie counting and tracking, poor body image

If you have a body, you probably have a few defining moments in your life when you’ve become especially aware of how others see it. Of course, some of us (most of us) are painfully aware of how our bodies are seen almost constantly, only occasionally managing to forget; but I expect everyone has one or two memories that stand out beyond the general static fuzz. For me, there is the primary school playground, aged about 8: we are walking into school, and my friend turns to me and says casually, “You’re actually quite fat, aren’t you?”

I vividly remember looking at my arms and my legs. I had thought they were just arms and legs – but, look, see how rounded they are, how could I have missed it? The fact that I’d never thought I was fat before seemed like evidence of how deluded I’d been. Thank goodness my friend had seen through it, seen through to a deeper truth about how my body really was.

I thought of this memory today when I saw the news about the new Weight Watchers app for children as young as 8 – as young as little me in the playground. When I was 8, we didn’t have smartphones, but we did have magazines and TV, and as I grew up they only confirmed what my so-called-friend had said: I was huge, I was enormous, I was way out of ‘normal’ range. I had some shorts that were age 13 when I was “only” 10, and I remember whispering to myself in horror, “I have the stomach of a thirteen year old.” As if thirteen year olds all have the same size stomach. As if that makes any sense at all.

Aged 12, I got a lovely new notebook with squared paper in it, and I noticed how nice the squares would be for drawing graphs. I decided to draw line graphs for the measurements of different parts of my body, my waist, my hips, my thighs. If I could measure, I could make the lines plot a beautiful downward trajectory, and craft a beautiful thin body. That was the idea, at least – I didn’t keep the measurements up very long. Like every attempt I’ve ever made to shrink my body, it didn’t work. Between the ages of 10 and 26 I have repeated the notebook graph attempt endless times in different forms: rules, points, and eventually apps. None of it ever worked.

All the way through school and university, I hovered around the size 12 – 14 mark. And I thought I was enormous. This isn’t a story about disordered eating – at least in a restrictive sense – because despite my best efforts, my body wouldn’t accept my giving it less food than it needed. But oh, did I try and make it. Over and over. Diet / fail / rinse / repeat. And all that time, I was below the national average size for women in the UK. But that didn’t matter. My friend in the playground was always there, seeing my body for what it really was, too big, too much.

When I developed depression in my early 20s, I began to get bigger, crossing over that national average and realising that I’d spent my teens worrying over nothing. I looked back wistfully of photos of my younger self, wishing I’d been able to appreciate my relative thin-ness at the time. At the same time, I began to learn about fat acceptance, health at every size, body positivity, institutionalised fatphobia, and all these things that meant that perhaps it wasn’t my fault. Perhaps society was wrong, not my body. Perhaps my friend in the playground was an 8 year old girl talking nonsense she’d seen on TV, not a prophet telling an essential truth about my body. But still, the idea haunted me that if I could just lose weight the right way – the body-positive, non-crash-diet, non-shaming good way, I could still do it. And I should. Out came the apps and the trackers and the step counters. Maybe if I did it with science it would be different. It wasn’t.

Things have only really changed this year, when I am the biggest I have ever been. For the first time, I am actually close to what I thought I was as a teen – too big to shop in the high street, bigger than society thinks is “normal”. I am a 20 – 22, which is not that far from that national average and considered pretty small in fat social media spaces, but it’s still big enough that most high street stores don’t want my custom. The reason my weight has changed this year in particular is because in January I hit my head and sustained a brain injury, which has meant that I have been fatigued and sedentary – and often urgently in need of a quick reviving snack – for most of the year. Dealing with the weight gain has been a process, but in a way the brain injury has made it easier. It was a relatively mild injury as brain traumas go, but it was severe enough to change my life, and it could have been much worse. If the imaginary eight year old friend in my head started to comment on my body, I suddenly had a reply for her and anyone else who had a problem with my body: “seriously, fuck you, I survived a brain injury“.

And then I realised, if I could say that to her now, I could actually have said that to her at any point in my life. In my early twenties, I could have said: “fuck you, I’m surviving depression!”. In my teens, “fuck you, I’m surviving being a teenager!”. And as an eight year old, “fuck you – I’m eight years old.” (Don’t say fuck you to actual eight year olds. Just imaginary ones in your head who’ve become symbolic of diet culture).

Brain injury recovery forced me to stop the cycle of dieting, abandoning dieting, then feeling bad about not dieting I’d been in for 15 years. For once it was unarguable: I had other shit to deal with. But allowing myself to stop the cycle made me realise that I have always had other shit to deal with. It has never been my fault that my body wasn’t what a warped beauty ideal dictated it should be. I have always been more important than my dress size.

And what a revelation it is! With this new fuck you to diet culture on my chest like a talisman, there is so much I can do. I can begin to free myself from the constant toxic mutter of body-hatred that used to drone through every day. I can take the time to look for clothes I like, in patterns that I like, that actually fit comfortably, because I don’t have to treat my body as temporary and soon-to-be-shrunk. I can meet my body where it is, not where I hope to force it to be at some future time. I can go swimming in my bright, joyful swimming costume covered in lemons. I can start, very slowly, to learn to listen to my body’s signals when it tells me it is full.

This was the intervention I needed as a very-slightly-chubbier-than-average eight year old. A holistic understanding of health; an awareness that nobody can see any ‘hidden truths’ about my body, that I am the only one who can truly know and understand it and what it needs. My heart hurts for the eight year olds who will be given the Weight Watchers app and get the exact opposite of this. The app is like my eight year old friend who I thought knew the truth about me, made into an all-knowing machine tracking my every move, and branded with a corporate logo. It’s like a high-tech version of my twelve year old thigh circumference graphs, which now just strike me as horribly sad. At the time I hid them assiduously, but I would hope that if an adult had seen them, they would have thrown them away for me, given me a hug, and told me my body was fine the way it was. I would hope they wouldn’t swap my notebook for an iPhone and say, “hey, there’s an app for that.”

We should be pushing for more radical and compassionate understandings of bodies and health, but instead the cultural push seems to be in the opposite direction. I wish we didn’t have to spend our time fighting horrible stuff like this. We’ve got other shit to be dealing with.

Categories
Uncategorized

The summer before you start teaching: anti-hacks and non-compulsory advice

This post is an adapted/expanded version of a thread I did last week for new teachers. I hope you’ll find it useful if you’re about to start teacher training, your NQT year, or about to move to a new phase or sector.

I have now been qualified as a teacher for 2 years. I love teaching, it fulfils me unlike anything I’d done before, but my path through the last 3 years has not been smooth. During my training year, I was going through some fairly intense NHS psychotherapy for chronic depression, which I still have. During my NQT year, I went directly into an SEN school after doing a mainstream training pathway, so had to quickly learn a whole new set of curriculum content, assessment structures and tools, as well as do medical and other kinds of training. This past academic year, my second in post, was running much more smoothly until I had an unlucky accident in January and went off work for several months, starting a phased return in May. I’m now part time until my injury recovery is still ongoing. So it’s been in-and-out, lots of crises, lots to manage. That means I don’t have a super-shiny set of clever workload hacks that are guaranteed to save you time, or a gorgeous pinterest-perfect classroom, or a fast-track-to-management plan. But I do have plenty of advice about starting (or re-starting) to teach, and dealing with the worries that can come with it.

The summer before I started my NQT year, I was desperately scouring the internet for advice articles. I’m going to try and write the article I needed to read at that time. I’m hoping it will also be the article you need, but it may not be, and that’s OK: one of the things I want to offer an antidote to here is the “10 hacks to survive in teaching” style of article. These may be useful to some people, but to me they always sent me into panic. Many “how to survive your NQT year” articles will give out advice beginning “Always…” or “Never…”. Never work on weekends. Always carry a [insert stationery item here]. Leave school at 5pm on the dot every day. In the early days of my teaching I would try and impose these on myself, using apps and trackers in the hope that changing my habits would control my stress levels, but I found that these attempts at rigid self-optimising always ended up making me more stressed. If that sounds like it might apply to you, read on. 

The thing that these “hacks” and rules are all trying to address is the Big Spectre haunting teaching: workload. It is widely known, by virtually everyone up to and including the Department for Education, that teachers have too much work to do. If you enter the teaching workforce, you are entering a job that can never be fully done, a job which is not designed to take the level of strain it is currently under. So almost all advice for “survival” in teaching is designed to help you survive as an individual in a structurally flawed system. That doesn’t mean it’s wrong to try and survive, and it doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t try. But I have found that the only way for me to keep going personally is to abandon the idea that the too-muchness of teaching can ever be overcome or solved with clever filing techniques or tracker apps. The feeling that there is more to do, that what’s already done could be done better, will never go away for me. The most useful thing I’ve learned is to sit with that feeling, examine it critically, and not let it drive me.

If you grew up in the UK, you might remember watching videos in PSHE about peer pressure and drug-taking. They may make better quality ones now, but in my day they were laughably unrealistic. There’s always an obvious bully, probably marked by a buzzcut and a bulldog-like expression, who says, “take the pills or you can’t be in our gang!”, and the video’s protagonist has to make an on-the-spot choice that determines her entire future. It’s funny and unrealistic because peer pressure is never that clear-cut: it’s subtle, it builds over time, and it rarely presents clear-cut “yes or no” moments. I think it’s the same with overwork in schools. Unless you work at a really extreme school, there’s unlikely to be somebody saying “Go home and work until midnight, and then be in school by 6.30am the next morning, or you’re fired”. I know this does happen, but in most schools the pressure to overwork is much subtler. There will be plenty of gaps into which it seems very easy to extend yourself, plenty of slack it will seem easy to take up, until suddenly it’s not easy. Setting myself rules about what time I had to leave never helped me resist these gaps: what helped was being mindful of the urge to constantly do more, and practising slowing down before I said “yes” to more tasks.

You will probably be told countless times as you start teaching that it is unwise to overwork yourself. You may be told this directly by managers and mentors. But quite often, in my experience, managers and mentors don’t give specifics about how not to overwork yourself, because much of it has become second-nature to them. You may, for example, be told to “prioritise” your to-do lists and only do the “most important” tasks – but how do you tell which ones are most important and need to be prioritised? Experienced teachers can forget that making these kinds of judgements is a skill which needs to be learned and practised as much as any classroom or behaviour support technique.

The sense that experienced teachers have of how long it will take to plan a lesson; of how much can be improvised in the moment and how much needs to be carefully written down; of how much time is truly essential for creating a resource that works, and how much is window-dressing with no real benefit to students; all these are instincts that come through time and experience and trial and error. You will probably make mistakes with them a few times. You will probably be up until a silly time cutting out 100 laminated pirate gold “coins” before you realise in the morning you could have just borrowed some play money (I did this). You will probably create some beautiful and intricate worksheets which will be scribbled on upside down (I also did this). This is OK: it is part of your learning process. You need to make mistakes like this to develop your sense of what needs doing, and when, and how important it is. It works both ways, too: you will probably at some point improvise a lesson on zero planning and find that it works beautifully, and that you’ve stumbled upon a low-prep activity that your class loves.

Through time and experience, you will learn to develop a critical distance from the work in front of you. You’ll learn to ask, who is it for? How essential is it? To whom? What would happen if I did half of it or none of it? There’s no magic formula, but getting used to asking these questions helps. You’ll also learn what matters to you; what you get satisfaction from; what kinds of work you know you hate and shouldn’t take on if you have any choice in it. You’ll learn which parts of the job you can tap into to find energy and motivation to get through the less fun bits. Very literally, you’ll learn what gets you through the day.

Imagining myself from two years ago reading this, I can feel my own anxiety and frustration: all right, this learning through experience thing is all very lovely, but how do I prepare? If you’re like me, you’ll still want concrete actions you can take, things to tick off to be able to say you’ve done all you can. So let me write out an imperative advice statement: you can prepare by getting used to the idea that you will never be fully prepared. Read it there on your screen, sit with how difficult it might feel. It is not possible to start this job and already be brilliant at it. Get used to asking yourself, and the people around you, what’s important. Get used to getting answers that might be confusing, and learning to make sense of them. Get used to leaving things less than perfect.

You’ve got so much ahead of you. Take a breath: you’ve got this. 

Categories
Uncategorized

Thinking through the fog: brain-work and cognitive fatigue

Just as I was rummaging around for a topic to write about, my friend Jess (twitter: @andiached) asked me if I’d ever written a post or a thread about doing thinking-based work – writing, academic work, etc – through fatigue and brain-fog. This happened to be on-the-nose for me yesterday, as I’d just worked up the courage to formally postpone a piece of writing I’d been asked to do, since I didn’t feel like I could do it justice with my current energy levels. Acknowledging this to myself was a hard thing to do, and it made me confront some of my own thinking about intellectual ‘output’. As I said to Jess, I haven’t got an answer on how to do intellectual work through periods of fatigue, but I certainly have some thoughts on it.

I’ve not really ever had a stable relationship with producing academic writing. Throughout my undergraduate degree, I worked with a verve and energy almost entirely fed by fear – I did enjoy what I was doing, but would never have done it at that intensity were it not for the incessant deadlines which I was disproportionately frightened of missing. When I tried to do postgraduate work, the constant deadlines and their accompanying terror-adrenaline shots disappeared, and so did my ability to motivate myself. I don’t know if my depression would have manifested itself at that point anyway (early 20s is supposed to be when lifelong mental health issues are likely to emerge, if they’re going to), but I do know that being stuck unable to ‘produce’ in academia was closely intertwined with the onset of my depression – and that, broadly speaking, is the story of how I failed to complete a PhD. So I don’t have much to go on in terms of a stable ‘baseline’ of working habits.

After a few years away from research, I started again this academic year, doing an MEd part-time while I worked. This model really suited me – I had the structure and grounding of school, but I was being given opportunities to reflect and write alongside it. However, everything had to stop when I hit my head in January. At first, I didn’t think it had to – I carried joining MEd online sessions from home – but it soon became clear I wasn’t going to be able to complete my research project while I wasn’t able to go into school, so I’ve had to pause it for a year. Like everything in my life since the accident, I’ve had to accept that my research and writing will have to come at a slower pace.

My brain injury gives me fatigue that operates on several fronts: the physical, the cognitive, and the sensory. These are by no means independent of one another, but usually my fatigue will be dominated by one of them. Sometimes I am able to walk around and lift things and do simple, repetitive tasks but I can’t plan or sequence anything more complex than folding laundry. Sometimes it hurts to get off the sofa, but I can sit and think and read articles and write. Sometimes I can’t really think or move and that’s when the all-day Gossip Girl marathons have to come out. And on some, precious days I can think, plan and move all at the same time.

While I’ve been off work, I’ve had more time to think and write, and plenty of new material to write about, but the work of getting from idea to page has got longer and more challenging. I can’t bury myself in researching and reference-chasing for hours – if I go too far without realising it, I’ll slam into a wall of cognitive fatigue I can’t negotiate with. This piece is confessional and not too academic, but I’ll probably still need a couple of hours of mindlessness afterwards since my brain will be tired after a period of sustained focus. The piece of writing I mentioned at the beginning, which I’d been planning to write for a friend, had to be put off because I realised that to do it justice I would need to read deeply, and grapple with the intricate process of integrating others’ ideas with my own – and I can’t do that yet. It was hard work before I hit my head, and at the moment it’s a task my injured brain isn’t strong enough for.

I am extremely lucky that, as a teacher, I have decent employment rights, and I haven’t suffered financially due to my injury since it occurred at work. My writing and research are pleasures, things I value deeply – but they are an add-on to my main source of income, and as such I don’t depend on them financially. An important limitation of what I write here is that I can’t speak for those who think and write as their main means of survival. A moving and thoughtful account of illness in ‘productivity’-culture from my friend Josie, a writer and philosopher, can be found here. Josie writes of her own writing about sadness and illness as “at least in part a sort of theoretical sicknote” aimed at her Patreon supporters, who function, she notes, as her “bosses”. This pressure to produce intellectual work, to “churn out takes” (as Josie writes), is one I only have to experience at a relatively safe distance.

Being able to write, to contribute to research, to communicate my ideas and perhaps help people with them, are important parts of my sense of self. Being in recovery from my injury has offered me time and a financial safety net to explore that part of myself, but also taken away much of the energy I would have needed to do it. I have found myself grasping at possible ideas, getting close to what feels like an argument but suddenly losing grip and energy and the flow of my sentence, over and over again. I have   had to become accustomed to the feeling that my thoughts now have to build in a slower, more repetitive, accretive process, like a stalagmite forming. Where I used to be able to push through to the end of a piece of writing, to reach a satisfying and triumphant conclusion, I have had to become accustomed to stopping when the fatigue wall hits and hoping – having faith – that I will be able to pick up my thoughts again. I have had to acknowledge that some types of output, like properly-referenced academic writing, are beyond me at the moment.

I think that coming to terms with these disruptions has forced me to be more flexible, more humble, more tentative in my thinking: it has prompted me to appreciate ways of knowing and thinking which are less linear, to begin to think about knowledge traditions which are less focused on the steady production of linear conclusions (Zoe Todd’s work, for example). These aren’t thoughts I can yet turn into a polished summary or a groundbreaking conclusion, but that’s kind of the point. I wish every chronically ill and fatigued person – and every person, really – had the luxury that I have had, to play with modes of thought, to go slowly and allow ideas to form when they’re ready, to defy the deadline. Unfortunately capitalism won’t allow this apart from in the small, undiscovered pockets it hasn’t yet fully managed to reach and dominate. Expanding the pockets of resistance is the real task, but unfortunately the fatigue has hit and I need to close my eyes for a while.

 

Categories
Uncategorized

We are all sensory beings

When you work in SEN, the word ‘sensory’ is a familiar one. We have sensory stories, sensory circuits, sensory rooms. And sometimes, certain children will be described as sensory learners, or even, sometimes, as just plain sensory – as in, “he’s really sensory”. As others have noted, these usages – especially the latter two – can be vastly over-applied, often tagged onto anything which involves texture or scent. And calling a child simply “sensory” is likely to be a vast over-simplification of their experience, placing an arbitrary limit on what they might be able to achieve or understand.

But the term needn’t always be used this way: Joanna Grace’s use of the term in her book Sensory Being for Sensory-Beings is careful and expertly considered. The book is a resource for those working with learners with profound and multiple learning disabilities (PMLD), but it is far more than that. In outlining her conception of a ‘Sensory Being’, Grace makes a distinction between those able to perceive and interpret the world through language – reading, writing, speech, or other communication forms such as signing – and those who “experience the world in a primarily sensory way”, who do not have the linearity and sequential understanding which comes with language but instead “live and respond in the now”. However, having sketched out this distinction, she then blurs and complicates it, talking about what those with linguistic and sensory modes of experience can teach and learn from each other. It is a model of practice which teachers in all kinds of setting can learn from. It has been particularly resonant in my mind recently, as I go through my own sensory learning experience recovering from brain injury.

About two months ago, two months into my recovery, I seemed to have hit something of a wall. I was doing my best to leave the house a few times a week, but each very short outing – a slow stagger to the end of the street – would leave me completely unable to do anything for several days afterwards, and my occupational therapist was ‘surprised’. The fatigue I was feeling didn’t seem to be proportionate to the distance I’d travelled; I seemed to be able to move around quite comfortably in my house, but not to travel the same distance outside. After an exhausting effort to convince my OT that her first theory – that I was anxious and avoidant of going outside due to mental health issues – wasn’t right, we began to look at other possibilities. I explained that unfamiliar places were much more tiring than familiar ones, and it felt like processing the sights and sounds of a new place was tiring me as much as walking was. It was later confirmed after cognitive tests that the injury had caused some damage to the areas of my brain which are able to filter out sensory distraction, and focus on relevant sensory information.

If you’ve never had any difficulties with sensory processing it might be hard to imagine what that feels like in practice, so let me explain. Imagine that you are outside, by the side of a road. If you have your sense of hearing, you will hear the noise of car engines as the cars speed past you. Assuming that you have been near roads before, and don’t have any particular anxieties around cars, this will likely not be alarming to you. In fact, you will probably not notice it – you might able to chat to your friend as you walk, or scroll on your phone. The car noises aren’t worrying to you and don’t take much of your attention.

Now imagine that you’re inside your house, and the sofa you’re sitting on starts to roar loudly like a whooshing car engine. It’s making exactly the same sound as the cars on the road outside did earlier. But you’re not likely to react in the same way; you’ll probably jump up in alarm, wondering where the sound is coming from, because sofa and roaring engine noise don’t normally go together. Until you work out why your sofa is roaring, you won’t be able to concentrate on anything else. This noise is going to take up all your attention. You’ll be required to engage your conscious brain until you work out what’s going on. When I first got out of hospital and went outside, each roar of a passing car was as alarming to me as the roaring sofa example. The process in my brain which labelled it “car noise – nothing to worry about” wasn’t working properly; it was tired and damaged. So each time I heard the car noise, I had to tell myself in my conscious brain, “it’s OK, it’s a car, you don’t need to worry”.

This isn’t normally a conscious process; I wasn’t used to having to tell myself what each familiar noise is. It was the same with visual input, too, especially with moving objects. Something zooming in your general direction at high speed? Highly alarming, unless you know it’s a car and you know that cars don’t generally mount the pavement. Something flapping in the corner of your eye? Definitely needs attention to make sure it’s not going to hit you – unless you know it’s a bird, and have remembered that birds don’t generally tend to dive-bomb directly at your head. It applied to my sense of touch and proprioception too – the first time I was on a bus, it felt like someone was shaking me like a bead inside a maraca.

The way I began to recover was through a kind of DIY exposure therapy: sitting outside for 5 minutes at a time and then longer and longer, consciously directing my attention to different sounds, practising labelling them until they became more and more automatic. Resting my eyes on the pavement when I went outside, then looking up more and more of the time. Sitting on the bus being shaken around and relaxing all my muscles, gently telling myself “the vibrations are from the bus, it’s OK” until I had done it enough times. Each new experience is the most exhausting the first time; once I have done it, it will be far easier the next. My brain is beginning to make sensory connections faster, and recover more quickly – the first train ride was much easier than the first bus trip. I am beginning to be able to do new things without the need to re-teach my senses how to experience them. But the experience of having to do it has been a fascinating one.

Throughout the last few months my thoughts have returned again and again to this beautiful blog post by Elly Chapple about her daughter, Ella. She describes the way that Ella, who is deafblind, taught herself about shoes:

I remember clearly when I watched Ella for a period of nine months repetitively work her way through the box of shoes at our front door. It’s a crate, nothing glamorous, but boxes are helpful for things having a place when you can’t see. She would sit daily, twice a day, prior to going anywhere and go through the entire shoe box, mouthing and feeling every single one. Laces, velcro (a favourite), zips, leather, suede, fabric, different sizes, smells and shapes. Something so simple, in my mind or yours, yet she would return to this daily without fault, twice a day. (…)

After nine months, one day she simply put the last shoe down, turned from the box and stood up. She sat down in her chair and promptly said ‘boots’ and indicated to her foot.

Elly reflects on her own reactions to Ella’s learning process, and the reactions of professionals around Ella:

I can also remember a professional suggesting this was ‘obsessive’ and it just didn’t sit with me that it was. Perhaps in a momentary observation without the whole view, it looked like that. It wasn’t what people sat and did regularly elsewhere. Or would they, if they were given the time and space to? I was fascinated by the ‘why’ and my ears numbed to the encouragement to ‘move her on’. The team and I knew that she was doing what she needed to. That without eyes, her hands had to work out every inch of every shoe and categorise that so by light touch she would know what we saw with our eyes in seconds – shoe, shoe, shoe, shoe. That had to be confirmed through touch, touch, touch and sometimes sound and smell.

Elly, who is with Ella all the time, knows her timescales and rhythms: a visiting professional does not. The visiting professional labels Ella’s learning as an “obsession”, an “othered” behaviour which should be “moved on” from. Elly, however, is curious: she trusts that Ella is ‘doing what she needed to’. I am reminded of my own experience with the occupational therapist, not being trusted to report my experience of moving through the world, having it consistently mis-labelled as ‘avoidance’ and ‘anxiety’. I have the privilege of a university-level education and can express myself in speech and writing among academics: in the world, I am generally read as ‘abled’ unless I am using a walking aid. In many ways, my life doesn’t compare to Ella’s. But it seems both she and I were not trusted by professionals to be in control of our own sensory experience.

There is more and more awareness of sensory needs, including those associated with autism and ADHD – as my OT put it once I finally convinced her I wasn’t avoidant and anxious, “sensory stuff is very in at the moment”. However, being in hasn’t translated into acceptance or understanding. Although some kinds of sensory regulation behaviour, such as spinning a fidget spinner or squeezing a stress ball, have become socially acceptable, others – such as vocalising – have not. And while mainstream schools are beginning to incorporate an awareness of sensory needs into their day, I often see it presented in terms of meeting needs so that students are “ready to learn”. I’d like to see more understanding that sensory experience is learning. The crowd of educators who like to insist that learning is a change in long-term memory will doubtless find this highly alarming – the idea that learning might take place in a less rigid, linear way than a simple  transfer of content from one cognitive brain to another is obviously highly upsetting to some. But whether or not we have access to language, we are all interacting with our environment through our senses in ways we don’t yet fully understand, and sensory integration is more than simply a box to tick before the ‘real’ learning can begin – it is learning, for me and for Ella and for everyone. Sensory being is the very stuff of life, the practice of learning how to move through the world. In the process of re-learning to process my sensory experience of the world, there have been joys too; the first feeling of sun on my face, an evening breeze, paddling in the sea. This experience has brought me closer to them. This poem, accidentally discovered, conveys some of what I feel:

The Waking

THEODORE ROETHKE

I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
I feel my fate in what I cannot fear.
I learn by going where I have to go.

We think by feeling. What is there to know?
I hear my being dance from ear to ear.
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.

Of those so close beside me, which are you?
God bless the Ground! I shall walk softly there,
And learn by going where I have to go.

Light takes the Tree; but who can tell us how?
The lowly worm climbs up a winding stair;
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.

Great Nature has another thing to do
To you and me; so take the lively air,
And, lovely, learn by going where to go.

This shaking keeps me steady. I should know.
What falls away is always. And is near.
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
I learn by going where I have to go.

img_1391

Grace, Joanna. Sensory-Being for Sensory Beings: Creating Entrancing Sensory Experiences (Page 9). Taylor and Francis. Kindle Edition.

Chapple, Elly. ‘The Deafblind world: The ‘Shoeness’ of a Shoe’. Special Needs Jungle, February 2019. (I have Elly’s consent to quote from her blog post and to talk about Ella).

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free