Before I started training as a teacher, one of the things I worried most about was “behaviour management”. There is an idea – exemplified in the ridiculous phrase “don’t smile until Christmas” – that new teachers will not have the required toughness or authoritarian heft to ‘control a class’ until they’ve perfected a stony-faced expression and impressed their stony-mindedness on their classes for several months in a row. I worried about this, because I am not, and have never been, tough. I have a soft face, a soft voice, and I’m a chronic people-pleaser. I tend to wear my emotions on my sleeve, and the idea of not smiling for several months in a row was ridiculous – how could I control my face for that long? My face just does what it wants. I did not think “behaviour management” would be a strength of mine.
As I moved through my training, it soon became apparent that my skill in “behaviour management” very much depended on what you meant by the term. My classrooms were often noisy, often a little chaotic, but I had good relationships with my classes. I realised over time that there was a split in my ability to ‘manage’ students. I was good at persuading students to do things I cared about them doing – ask me when you need help, work together, give things a try, don’t hurt others. I remember I once explained to a pair of year 7 boys why they should stop saying the word “triggered” as a joke, going into detail about how it trivialises PTSD, and was stunned by the sincerity of their apology and commitment not to say it again. I think they had responded to my own sincerity in asking them. Conversely, I wasn’t at all effective with rules I didn’t believe in. Chewing gum, forgetting your pencil, looking out the window or not wearing your uniform properly – I just didn’t care about these things. When I performed caring about them because it was expected of me, my students saw right through it.
This is one of many reasons I could never survive teaching in a zero tolerance/no excuses school. The idea behind these schools’ policies is that compliance itself is a virtue worth teaching: that students need to learn the skill of compliance so that they can go on to be compliant as adults. This is not grand theorising on my part: it’s very clear in the policies themselves, which emphasise following instructions straight away without question. It’s all there in the ‘No Excuses’ slogan – nothing you might say to explain or excuse your behaviour will change the punishment I, an adult, am giving you. My word is law because it is my word.
It’s important not to forget that, as teachers, we are all relying on some degree of compliance. Fundamentally, our students are all compelled to be there (via legal obligations on their parents), so we can’t pretend to be operating in an environment totally free of force and obligation. As well as simply being in the room, we need to be able to prevent our students from coming to harm: we need to know that if we say “stop” as they are running out into the road, they will listen. Beyond that, it’s mostly about convenience and the logistics of having a large group of people together in one room. We might want students to lower their voices when asked so that we can hear ourselves think in the classroom. We might want them to pick up their stuff from the floor so the room doesn’t get in a mess. I found that I was by far the most effective at persuading students to do these things if I explained why I wanted them. “Please remember to write the date, because when I mark your books it takes me ages to find the work otherwise” proved much more effective than implying that there’s any intrinsic moral value in writing the date. “Please be a little quieter so we can all hear what we’re doing, plus it’s really boring and annoying for all of us if I have to keep shushing you all the time” proved much more effective than trying to enforce silence for its own sake.
In some ways, zero tolerance/no excuses settings are explicit about this dynamic. They have no shame in stating that you should act in ways which are convenient for your teacher. The difference is that they assign this compliance-with-convenience moral virtue, and make it totally non-negotiable. While it might be more convenient for me if all my students are quiet while they’re working, it’s not what they naturally want to do, and so there’s a negotiation: how much am I going to try to persuade them to act differently, and how much is it worth it? In zero tolerance/no excuses there is no such negotiation: the teacher learns that they automatically have the right to dictate their will. They don’t have to think about why they want something, or the balance of benefits and drawbacks for everyone in the room. The student learns to comply with the person in power, and learns that compliance is good.
You might think, then, that zero tolerance/no excuses schools would be perfectly positioned to impose the mask-wearing mandate that’s recently been introduced (or has it? or will it be? I have no fucking clue any more, honestly) for secondary schools. Come September, I was fully expecting to see gloating photos of perfectly masked-up children in ZT/NE schools, along with snarky comments about how don’t we all wish we worked in schools where students were conditioned to do what they were told? Surely if there is one argument for compliance, it’s the example above about running out into the road, and a mass public health crisis seems to be about as close to that as we’re going to get. Don’t these people love uniforms?
It seems I will be spared the gloating class photos, however, because the ZT/NE crowd have come out against masks. In retrospect this was predictable: they are deeply connected to the far right, and rely on being able to broadcast their dog whistles in the education sphere. The far right have decided anti-mask sentiment is a handy talking point and recruitment tool – quite a clever one, since masks are kind of annoying and uncomfortable, the government’s policy on them has been totally inconsistent and confusing. And so the ZT/NE media stars have to be anti-masks too, which puts them in a fascinating rhetorical position: they must simultaneously claim that their schools create perfect environments of compliance, and also that it would be cataclysmic to ask their students to do something according to a government directive. If they can make their students walk silently through the corridors; if they can make them track teachers with their eyes at all times (yes, they do this: google SLANT); if they have the incredibly high levels of attendance they claim to have; can they not make them wear masks? Can they not make them behave sensibly with a mask on?
The answer is obvious: they could, but they don’t want to. This is what’s laid bare by the convoluted rhetorical gymnastics they’re doing in order to stick to the far right anti-mask hymn sheet. When it really comes down to it, they’re like me. They don’t want to enforce rules they don’t care about. Their claim to be teaching compliance as a moral virtue and useful life skill falls apart: it’s not that they want kids to be able to follow rules in general. They want kids to be able to follow their rules that they like, and they only like rules that perpetuate hierarchy and prop up their ideological project.
In resisting this, I think we need to be careful that we’re not just echoing the ZT/NE compliance obsession. I know it’s frustrating that such an apparently simple thing is being turned into an extremist talking point: believe me, I spend most of my time freaked out about this kind of thing. But responding with incredulity that anyone could possibly be so stupid as to doubt mask-wearing is playing into the far right’s hands. Anti-mask feeling is such an effective recruiting tool because it plays on people’s confusion and powerlessness in the face of the pandemic. Yelling “WEAR A MASK, STUPID” just fuels that. We can’t just expect compliance for its own sake. We have to make our case, we have to say why it matters, we have to build relationships.Our media and political discourse are in a terrible, terrifying place, and I’m not naïve enough to think that just being ourselves and hoping for the best will fix it all. But I know that I was never able to persuade people based on compliance first: I had to tell them why I cared.




